Is Punishment Or Reward The More Powerful In Motivating Employees?

774 words, 4 pages

Intro Sample...


They may therefore have to offer a slightly different set of incentives from worker to worker. For example, a job promotion will satisfy the esteem needs. Some managers punish workers by removing the lower-level needs, which will cause their need to reverse to the lower needs.

Frederick Herzberg research was influenced by an interview study to select potential candidates. He believes in a two-factor theory of motivation. He argues that there are certain factors that organization can introduce to motivate employees to work harder (Motivators). However, there are also factors which will dissatisfy an employee if absent, but these do not motivate employees. (Hygiene factors)

Motivators are related to the job, such as how much opportunity it gives for extra responsibility, recognition and promotion. Herzberg believes that management can motivate workers by giving them recognition for their achievements and career advancement.

Hygiene factors are external factors like salary and work conditions. Management can punish workers by reducing salary or downgrading the work condition. They can reward workers by providing them as incentives. Herzberg felt that the carrot and stick approach is only effective in the short-run as they are not the motivators.

Douglas McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y encompass a negative and positive view in assumption of human behaviours. Theory X manager assumes that an average person is a lazy person, who dislikes work and tends to avoid it. Management needs to promote incentive schemes to motivate him or coerce and threaten with punishment, so that he will put in adequate efforts to achieve organization’s objectives.

In contrast, Theory Y manager assumes that an average person was eager to work as it could offer satisfaction. Threat of punishment is not required to motivate a person. Satisfying an average View More »

Read More

Related Essays on Is Punishment or Reward the More Powerful in Motivating Employees?

  • Riordan Probelm Solution

    7699 words, 31 pages

    Problem Solution: Riordan Manufacturing Employee motivation is an issue that does not discriminate (UoP, 2008). “Motivation is the willingness to exert effort in a particular way” (Dreher & Dougherty, 2001, p.28). Two theories can be reviewed when examining motivation. The first is expectancy theory. Expectancy theory holds that people are motivated to behave in ways that produce desired combinations of expected outcomes (Kreitner & Kinicki, 2004). Vroom’s expectancy theory is a mathematical model that looks at motivation. Employee motivation is influenced by expectation. If I get a raise at

    View Document »

    Riordan Problem Solution And Defense

    7031 words, 29 pages

    Running head: PROBLEM SOLUTION: RIORDAN MANUFACTURING Problem Solution: Riordan Manufacturing University of Phoenix Problem Solution: Riordan Manufacturing The objective of this paper is to exhibit an organized approach using the 9-step Problem-Solving Approach to provide Riordan Manufacturing with legitimate solutions to challenges presented. In addition, the paper identifies opportunities and issues, defines the problem, and develops a set of alternative solutions. In conclusion, the paper recommends the paramount alternatives to implement in order for Riordan Manufacturing to

    View Document »

    Strategic Human Resources Research

    5837 words, 24 pages

    Riordan Manufacturing is facing a decline in morale and work ethics. Declining sales and uneven profits over the years not only forced the company to change its sales processes, but also prompted them to adopt a customer-relationship system. Riordan’s HR reward and compensation policy program needs to be revised to deal with the existing problem. HR professionals over the world know that their toughest job is recruiting and retaining top-notch employees for their companies. With unemployment at its current rate, expanding businesses search for qualified workers like big-game hunters stalking t

    View Document »

    Intersect Investment Problem Solution

    6177 words, 25 pages

    Problem Solution: Intersect Investment Services Intersect Investment Services (IIS) is a financial services industry company which has been struggling to survive in a market which has been in constant state of flux, never certain and always chaotic (University of Phoenix, 2008). IIS has “barely managed to survive, but resisted making a drastic, strategic shift” (University of Phoenix, 2008, p. 1). The changed market conditions have led to the changed vision of IIS which is: “Provide a broad set of products and services to consumer and small business customers using a model of customer intimac

    View Document »

    Problem Solution: Riordan Manufacturing

    3023 words, 13 pages

    Problem Solution: Riordan Manufacturing Riordan Manufacturing (Riordan) is a global plastics company owned by a Fortune 1000 enterprise, Riordan Industries. It produces plastic beverage containers in Albany, Georgia, custom plastic parts in Pontiac, Michigan and plastic fan parts in Hangzhou, China. Riordan's Research and Development is conducted in San Jose, California, corporate headquarters. Declining sales and profits has forced Riordan to change its sales processes and adopt a customer-relationship management system (CRM). A team approach was implemented with the expectation that sales

    View Document »

    Career Developmen Plan- Uop Kudler Fine Foods

    3264 words, 14 pages

    Since my promotion as Human Resource Manager at Kudler Fine Foods, I have been working extremely hard to work on my career development plan for my new team at our La Jolla store. A much needed purchasing manager will be hired, and four new positions will open up for our new Supervisor in Training Program (SIT). It has been made clear to me that my team at will be hired to train in La Jolla and upon completion of Carlsbad location they will move there to train other new employees, and will become part of the supervisory team. Due to this team preparing for supervision responsibilities the

    View Document »

    Operational Effectivess

    4547 words, 19 pages

    Most of the company’s have a performance measurement and management system which deals with enhancing the performance of individuals or operations in a company, may it be a manufacturing or a non- manufacturing company. Performance measurement (PM) is a useful tool that helps the company reach its goals, and goals are straightforwardly described by Goldratt as, “the goal of a firm is to make money’, and without the right performance of individuals and operations, it cannot reach its goals. (TXTBK OPERATIONS MGT FOR COMPETITIVE EDGE). First will define PM, and explain the use of PM in comtemp

    View Document »

    Ford Motor Company

    4528 words, 19 pages

    Ford Motor Company: An Analysis of Employee Motivation and Morale Table of Contents Overview 2 Introduction 3 Clues from History 3 Ford & the Other Guys 6 Innovation & Motivation 8 The Family 12 Cutbacks 13 Conclusion 15 Works Cited 16 Overview The purpose of the following paper is to inform the reader about possible techniques of behavior modification in an attempt to solve motivational problems with workers at Ford Motor Company. Information on the company’s history, current and future outlooks, and human resource problems will lay the foundation to apply prov

    View Document »

    Global Communications Problem Solution

    4198 words, 17 pages

    Abstract This paper is about the issues that Global Communications (GC) is facing as they try to increase profits by outsourcing and partnering with another company. The topics that will be discussed range from the issues GC is facing to the dissatisfaction of the Union. Global Communications Problem Solution Global Communications (GC), a telecommunications company is facing numerous dilemmas due to a decline in the telecommunications industry. As a result, stock prices have plummeted in the last three years. In order to rebound and achieve new growth in a competitive industry, Global C

    View Document »

    Analyse And Critically Discuss The Nature And Purpose Of The Employment Relationship For Organizations And The Relationship Between Work Design, Planning, Pay And The Employment Relationship. Explain How Expectancy Theory; Reinforcement Theory An...

    4324 words, 18 pages

    Analyse and critically discuss the nature and purpose of the employment relationship for organizations and the relationship between work design, planning, pay and the employment relationship. Explain how expectancy theory; reinforcement theory and equity theory help managers to build an effective pay strategy as part of managing employment relationships Words: 2,695 . Introduction The term ‘employment-relationship’ is interchangeable with others when describing aspects of the overall relationship. According to USQ (2004) this relationship is basically the exchange of work

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!