Predation As A Fact

638 words, 3 pages

Intro Sample...


Phil 2

McMahan begins his argument to do away with predation with the assertion that animals are in great agony when they are killed by predators. He doesn’t give any proof of this, but that might be because he is building off of Singer’s Animal Liberation. In Animal Liberation, Singer explains in detail how animals are capable of feeling pain and how similar their experience of pain is to the human experience. Then to connect Singer’s argument to McMahan’s point, one just has to have seen how prey is killed by predators. To witness a wolf ripping apart a rabbit while it is still breathing is to see pain being inflicted.
His second premise is that animal suffering is objectively bad, just like how human... View More »

Body Sample...



An objection to my objection would be what if the roles of predation were reversed. What if thousands of humans were being devoured by animals? Should we intervene to save them even though the animals are not choosing to kill humans because of some rational about morality? We of course would want to say yes because the thought of letting all those people simply be food for animals is a terrifying one. So why would we help humans from being devoured but not animals? While it is true that the humans being devoured is simply a morally neutral fact like animals eating animals, it is perfectly acceptable to dislike that fact and fight against it. In this way we can save the people from the man-eating animals, but we would morally be required to. By this logic some may desire the end of predation for aesthetic or supererogatory reasons, but we have no moral compunction to desire the end of predation.
...

Read More

Related Essays on Predation as a Fact

  • The Defense For The Predators

    424 words, 2 pages

    Phil 2 The view by that constant animal suffering on Earth gives humans reason to desire the extinction of all predatory animal species is purported by philosopher Jeff McMahon. He asserts several points in defense to his argument. I will refute his most relevant claims by using Peter Singer’s argument against “speciesism” and closely analyzing each of McMahon’s points. McMahon’s biggest defense for extinction of all carnivores is that it would be good to prevent the vast suffering and countless violent deaths caused by predation. His assumption that the end of all

    View Document »

    Gender In Us Islamic And Orthodox Jewish Sacred Spaces

    6514 words, 27 pages

    ASMST 150 Introduction Across the globe there are millions of mosques and synagogues that serve as sacred sites for Muslims and Jews respectively. Each sacred site serves different purposes, including refuge for those less fortunate, a community center for the ethnic, a place of religious thought, a place of worship and prayer, and a place to share and rejoice with one another. The list goes on and on, but the underlying theme of all sacred sites is that they are to be a place of pilgrimage on the local, national, and global level. But pilgrimage for whom? There

    View Document »

    Invisible Man Lit Analysis Of The Modern Era

    1874 words, 8 pages

    One’s existence and individual identity is highly affected by his/her surroundings and the society he/she lives in. People are the clay for society’s hands to mold, which is exactly what happens in Invisible Man. Invisible Man is a novel about exactly what the title states: an invisible man. The main character has no name which emphasizes the fact that he is transparent in, not his physical appearance, but his overall existence. The setting of this novel takes place in post-1920’s, when a lot of changes were occurring because of the shift in time periods, also known as the Modern era. The twen

    View Document »

    Bally Total Fitness Recommendation

    5736 words, 23 pages

    UGBA 106 Introduction The health club industry is an industry that is plagued with rapid growth and increasing competition. Clubs are struggling to stay competitive niche and emerging markets while remaining profitable. Many clubs seek multiple forms of revenue, Bally Total Fitness (Bally’s) being no exception. As one of the largest health conglomerates, Bally’s has had an interesting past riddled with successes and challenges. In the past few years, Bally’s has been largely scrutinized and has struggled to maintain positive net income and declining stock prices. This report serves as a re

    View Document »

    Person-first Language, Is It Actually Necessary?

    2870 words, 12 pages

    Disability and language is a major topic in society; people feel offended or excluded due to labels. Person-first language was thus created to allow people with disabilities to feel more included in society and not feel looked-down upon. It is now enforced to say “person with a disability” rather than “disabled person” as to not have them feel excluded. But is this really all that effective? If looked under a light of language, it seems ridiculous to rearrange words and extend sentences just to cater to people’s sensitive needs. Language is meant to be short and concise, whereas person-first l

    View Document »

    An Obsession

    2950 words, 12 pages

    For many years, accountability and standardized testing has dominated the realm of education. It was thought that accountability would help drive education and boost student performance. Standardized testing is the way they chose to measure this increased student achievement. Placing high target goals, like the goal of 100% proficiency on schools across the nation, is thought to motivate academic excellence. However, studies have shown that the accountability measures being implemented are highly ineffective. While it is true test scores on standardized tests have improved, these scores may no

    View Document »

    Students And Prewriting

    3378 words, 14 pages

    The writing process is composed of many interrelated and equally important steps – Prewriting, Drafting, Writing, and Revising. All of these stages build off one another and guide students towards a polished final product. However, studies show that students do not necessarily devote an equal amount of time and energy to all parts; in fact, most students will only focus on one or two of the four proposed steps. One step in particular that is heavily neglected is the prewriting step. There are a number of reasons why students often opt out of this particular step, but this research paper will e

    View Document »

    Bailout

    3077 words, 13 pages

    UGBA107 Coming into his first term as President, a huge controversial issue that President Obama had to take a stand on was whether or not to bailout American car company General Motors, as the company was strongly affected by the weak United States economy. After advocating and eventually handing out a huge bailout several years ago, General Motors is again in the spotlight because of its large amounts of investment in plants in Mexico to outsource work. Many American taxpayers believe it is wrong for General Motors to give jobs to non-Americans especially after the huge government bailou

    View Document »

    Foreign Investments In Central Asia: Past, Present, And Future

    7354 words, 30 pages

    GEO55 Introduction Since their independence in 1991 Central Asian states have each struggled to keep up with the innovations and economies of the modern world. Much of the development in each country is contingent upon the ability for countries to gain foreign investment to build infrastructure and economies. In this paper I will analyze the state of Central Asian economies as they pertain to the natural resources, infrastructure, human resources, and government in each respective state. Each of these four categories helps define the current state and the future of foreign investment i

    View Document »

    Neilsen And Uber

    1084 words, 5 pages

    UGBA161 1a. The Nielsen system at the time of the article had many apparent flaws. The first notable flaw was the fact that ratings may have been statistically wrong. The example that The Atlantic Monthly gives is the show Murphy Brown earning a rating of 15 with a standard error of sixth tenths of a ration point in either direction. The article goes on to state that these errors were merely “on paper” and that in the “real world” the degree of error may be even worse. The second big error was tracking actual viewers, especially with “button fatigue”. Many viewers would not click their but

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!