Should Teachers Grade On A Curve

1009 words, 5 pages

Intro Sample...


English 103

Grading on a curve tends to be a hot topic especially among students and teachers. Nobody wants a bad grade, but is the classic bell curve grading the way to go about things? The idea is that the grades in a class should overall match what is called a bell curve with the majority of grades falling in the B to C range with a couple D/F and a couple A. This is done by deciding the student’s grade not based upon the raw score but instead how their score compares to the other students’ scores. Authors Eugene Volokh and Adam Grant wrote articles for and against respectively on the issue. There are plenty of arguments on either side of grading on a standard bell curve which are important to keep in mind, however sometimes the... View More »

Body Sample...


This is an unrealistic message to send to students. In a work environment it pays in the long run to be cooperative and a good teammate. Employers look for individuals that can support others as they strive for their own personal success at the same time. The curve is teaching that the only way to succeed is for others to fail. It builds a “culture of cutthroat cooperation” (Grant). This is stating that students cooperate with each other in the classroom but each one is still in to beat out everybody else. It is a battle with the rest of the class to see who will end up with a good grade on the test or in the class. Both authors bring up good points on the grading curve, so if we put the best points of each together there can be a compromise. A different type of curve can appease both sides.

Looking at the arguments on both sides there seems that there should be a better way to grade. Grant, like Volokh, is a teacher and also wrote about his solution that he tested out on his students. After reading the arguments on both sides I have found that I really like Grant’s new grading strategy. The downsides of using the curve is specific to the traditional bell curve used, while the upsides dealt mainly with the importance of a curve in general. Grant came up with the idea of not completely discarding the idea of a curve, but simply curving in a different way. He made a rule that no student’s grade would be hurt because of another student’s success. This means he would only curve upwards. This allows for those struggling due to a difficult test to still get the curve they ...

Read More

Related Essays on Should Teachers Grade on a Curve

  • Students And Prewriting

    3378 words, 14 pages

    The writing process is composed of many interrelated and equally important steps – Prewriting, Drafting, Writing, and Revising. All of these stages build off one another and guide students towards a polished final product. However, studies show that students do not necessarily devote an equal amount of time and energy to all parts; in fact, most students will only focus on one or two of the four proposed steps. One step in particular that is heavily neglected is the prewriting step. There are a number of reasons why students often opt out of this particular step, but this research paper will e

    View Document »

    An Obsession

    2950 words, 12 pages

    For many years, accountability and standardized testing has dominated the realm of education. It was thought that accountability would help drive education and boost student performance. Standardized testing is the way they chose to measure this increased student achievement. Placing high target goals, like the goal of 100% proficiency on schools across the nation, is thought to motivate academic excellence. However, studies have shown that the accountability measures being implemented are highly ineffective. While it is true test scores on standardized tests have improved, these scores may no

    View Document »

    Bullying

    5612 words, 23 pages

    Historically, in cases of peer-to-peer abuse, whether physical or emotional, the blame is laid on the belligerent boys or girls. The bystanders who hover, chime in, or squirm on the outskirts of the 'mean' action are dismissed as irrelevant. Also dismissed are those who spread the tale of the victim's woe through the grapevine. In truth, however, this supporting cast plays a significant role in peer-to-peer violence....Bystanders make or break bullying episodes." (Our Children) This article examines the role of the bystander in bullying incidents and outlines some strategies to help enc

    View Document »

    Economic Analysis Of Wesfarmers Coal

    2433 words, 10 pages

    1. Introduction The Wesfarmers Coal division, with mining interests throughout Australia, is part of Wesfarmers Limited, a major diversified Australian public company. They only produce thermal (steam) coal and metallurgical (coking) coal, with the latter being exported (Figure A). As shown in Figure B coking coal is priced much higher than thermal coal. The firm’s coal interests include the Curragh mine in Queensland’s Bowen Basin, the Premier Coal mine at Collie in Western Australia’s south west, and a 40 per cent interest in the Bengalla mine in the Hunter Valley of New South Wales.

    View Document »

    The Effects Of Intergrating Writing Into The Writing Process

    2857 words, 12 pages

    Abstract: This study was conducted over an 8- week period with 20 first graders in an urban school setting. Students simply wrote on self-selected topics without drawing. During the first week students were limited to writing in a 30 minute time frame. Two weeks later students were timed for 30 minutes again and they were asked to draw and then write. Results showed that when students draw and then write their stories, their writing performance increased. Changes to their writing center occurred during this 8-week period. Hence, their feelings toward writing also increased at the end o

    View Document »

    Effective Study Skills And Academic Performance

    4278 words, 18 pages

    Introduction Effective study skills are necessary for a college student to excel academically. The student must develop these skills in order to retain information learned in the present for their future benefit. Study skills can be a combination of several techniques, including time management, note-taking, self-testing, and test-wiseness, to name a few. There is no one best way to study, therefore, techniques can be tailored to the needs of the student to achieve the most optimal result. However, diagnostic testing is also available to assist students in assessing their weaknesses in thei

    View Document »

    Aligning Education Systems

    3962 words, 16 pages

    Since it’s implementation in 2002, the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) has been intended to boost student achievement and hold schools accountable for students’ progress. This act was met with sweeping support. The business ideals incorporated into the act in the form of accountability were thought to produce achievement in students just like in the business world. However, the act that was passed with flying colors was quickly met with concerns. One of the biggest flaws of NCLB was that it called for 100% proficiency on standardized tests nationwide by all students by the year 2014. The targe

    View Document »

    My Life

    2423 words, 10 pages

    The amount factors that influence a person’s upbringing are uncountable. Arguably, the younger a child is the more prone to influence they are. At a young age, what one learns and the environment in which they learn it will shape their work ethic and willingness to learn for all the years to come. Fortunately for me all of years of reaching maturity were exceptionally positive. In this paper I will attempt to outline the major aspects of my development and how these have shaped my values. I grew up in the Alpharetta/Roswell area (just outside of Atlanta), a sparsely populated yet relativ

    View Document »

    Regulating Broadband In Chile: The Debate Over Open Access

    2017 words, 9 pages

    UGBA101A 1. Telephone companies were given the opportunity to set their own prices unless Chile’s antitrust agency determined that there was not sufficient competition for a certain service or geographical region. As a result, the telecommunications regulatory agency, known as SUBTEL, would determine the maximum price the dominating firm could charge for the given service or region. However, firms outside of the one dominating were allowed to set any price they saw fit and could change the prices whenever they desired. The price that SUBTEL ultimately established was reliant upon assumptio

    View Document »

    Under The Feet Of Jesus Response Paper

    766 words, 4 pages

    Helena Maria Viramontes’s Under the Feet of Jesus depicts the false reality of the “American Dream”. She confronts issues of inequality in areas such as education and class, and reveals how these inequalities all tie into race. As the details of Estrella and her family’s life unravels throughout the novel, Viramontes is able to shatter the illusion of the American dream while highlighting the ways in which society has created this false identity that excludes minorities from equal opportunities. Early on in the novel, Estrella personally experiences marginalization while at school. Her teac

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!