The Defense For The Predators

424 words, 2 pages

Intro Sample...


Phil 2

The view by that constant animal suffering on Earth gives humans reason to desire the extinction of all predatory animal species is purported by philosopher Jeff McMahon. He asserts several points in defense to his argument. I will refute his most relevant claims by using Peter Singer’s argument against “speciesism” and closely analyzing each of McMahon’s points.
McMahon’s biggest defense for extinction of all carnivores is that it would be good to prevent the vast suffering and countless violent deaths caused by predation. His assumption that the end of all suffering deaths caused by predation is a good thing fails on two accounts. First, he fails to take into account “predation” in the microbial level. Numerous bacteria on Earth that kill other bacteria are vital to all living organisms. Virtually all, living organisms house predatory bacteria that feed on other bacteria in order to multiply. However, these bacteria also decompose harmful pathogens and aid in absorbing nutrients for survival. For example, in Humans, lactic acid bacteria kill pathogens in the stomach that cause diarrhea. In fact, the elimination of all predating microbes would wipe out all living creatures on earth due to diseases. Although according to McMahon, these causes “animal suffering”, most people would not desire the elimination of all predating bacteria. Suppose McMahon changes his argument to limit carnivores to those visible to the human eye, Singer would label his argument speciesist. He would be allowing the suffering of certain carnivorous animals over another in consideration of their visibility. Second, in advocating the ending of animal suffering caused by predation, he implies the absence of animal suffering among herbivores. However, this is easily proven false through looking at a group of mammals, insects, and birds that compete over pinyon pine seeds. In particular areas where chipmunks and squirrels are abundant, the cone-boring insect p View More »

Read More

Related Essays on The Defense for the Predators

  • Warning Of Sexual Predators Online And Off

    1507 words, 7 pages

    Latasha Thomas Composition I Final Project Today's society can be a scary and dangerous place, if not properly prepared for it. Some things must be put in place to protect those who can't necessarily protect themselves. That is why I want to let parents and children know about sexual predators that may come around them or adults who make them feel uncomfortable. Never is it ok for an adult to touch a child inappropriately, or abuse them sexually. As adults we owe it to children to ensure their safety against sexual predators among us, online and off. There are

    View Document »

    Legal Competency And The Court

    9536 words, 39 pages

    Abstract The subject of competency of an accused individual to stand trial has remained a part of jurisprudence more or less since trials became a part of the system. In the middle ages the accused that were infirm were tortured until they either confessed that they were fit to stand trial, were severely injured, or died during the process. As an example those that had been accused of a crime who were mute had increasingly heavier weights

    View Document »

    Criminal Defense

    1025 words, 5 pages

    University of Phoenix When an individual is charged with a crime, the individual has the right to defend her or himself with the best legal defense and representation available. Criminal defense lawyers represent ordinary individual charged with any violation of the law. There are numerous criminal defenses that are used. Criminal defenses range and vary depending on the crime that the individual is being charged. Many have heard of the insanity defense and self defense being used, but the use of gay panic defense and urban survival syndrome are not used as often by criminal defense lawyer

    View Document »

    Procedures Of Criminal Trial

    2682 words, 11 pages

    One of the most vaguely understood events in the United States is the modern criminal trial. Most people have a faint knowledge of the goings-on of criminal proceedings, mainly due to what is seen on television, but the person who knows the real course of a trial is rare. However, there is nothing mysterious about the events that determine criminal guilt. Trials are carefully orchestrated, following procedures that have been laid in legal concrete over the years, and generally follow the same basic format across the United States. Criminal law is distinguishable from c

    View Document »

    Sex Offenders The Oklahoma Containment Model

    5192 words, 21 pages

    Sex Offenders & the Oklahoma Containment Model: What Is Being Done and What Should Be Done David A. Kirby, M.S. Northeastern State University Abstract Oklahoma has made a priority of dealing with the problem of repeat sex offenders. The current approach is based on the plan utilized in the State of Pennsylvania. The historical approach has been that many well-meaning agencies have independently attempted to manage sex offenders and provide protection for victims. This independence has kept these agencies and o

    View Document »

    Chipmunks Behaviors

    1255 words, 6 pages

    Chipmunk The chipmunk is one of nature’s smallest animals. The chipmunk can be described as having a light brown belly and four dark brown or black stripes. These dark stripes are separated by white stripe that run the length of the animal’s body. The chipmunk is a very short animal only about six inches in height and one foot in length. To prevent predators from invading the chipmunk’s habitat their appearance does not change color to avoid them being hunted. The chipmunk instead, will run from the forest floor to escape from predators. It will run and jump using

    View Document »

    Gain High Slayer Xp Runescape 2007 Money

    1255 words, 6 pages

    Old school runescape gold at rsorder with low price, 5mins delivery and no confirmation for paypal users! Interfaces should probably be uploaded separately, and as graphical updates tends to create a new file every time some part of the interface is significantly altered (such as a new skill being released), they should probably be located on a new page. Not quite sure how to handle them if they replace the cheap rs 07 gold current system beyond recognition rather than just add to it. just saying. I already told Spine that me, him, sword frog, basically every image contributer is going HARD AS

    View Document »

    National Missial Defense

    1867 words, 8 pages

    In Andrew Jackson?s farewell address to the nation, he stated, ?We shall more certainly preserve peace when it is well understood that we are prepared for war,? (Political Quotations #3719). The United States has always throughout history been a major military power from the use of abnormal tactics during the Revolutionary War (1776) to the use of its technology and advanced weapons in the Persian Gulf War (1991). After World War II and the Cold War Era, the United States has been able to defend its citizens from any form of a military attack from the sea, air, and the ground

    View Document »

    The Courtroom Workgroup And Plea Bargaining

    1772 words, 8 pages

    The judicial system is a system that involves several courts that interpret and apply law respectfully to the facts of a particular case. According to the Wikipedia (2015) the judicial system “provides a mechanism for the resolution of disputes”. The judicial system has several roles that work together on a daily basis to make decisions in reference to cases that have been produced. The overall group of the court system is known as the Courtroom Workgroup. Each individual has a particular role in the Courtroom Workgroup that hold different ethical obligations to the welfare of the client, t

    View Document »

    I’m Leaving Home, But Don’t Worry I Have You In Myspace

    1466 words, 6 pages

    Let us imagine the following scenario is 1960 and a graduation is about to finish. All the graduates are hugging each other, crying, and promising that no matter what happens they will always remember each other and they will always maintain a relationship. But eventually some of the graduates got into different colleges or some moved to another state and whatever the reason, graduating from high school meant, for some of them, the end of a lifetime friendship. Back in the day, people struggled to maintain contact with their friends whether they moved to another state, or got into different co

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!