Issues In Reconstruction

317 words, 2 pages

Intro Sample...


NES140

The main issues that center around the reconstruction the life of Muhammad are the validity and extent of validity of sources. Most sources are dated to two or three centuries after Muhammad passed, so this can also make sources questionable, although many believe that they are preserved because of the Islamic verbal tradition.
Controversy within sources mainly lies in hadith material. Ignaz Goldziher was one of the first scholars to challenge the validity of the hadith material, material that was before used by most scholars. He stated that the origin of the information is not clear, making the hadiths unreliable. In addition, without a basic chronological and topographical framework provided by the Muslim tradition, even sources like the Qur’an become almost useless for a historian trying to compile a biography on Muhammad.
Still, many historians continued to write historical accounts of Muhammad. Many believed that although many sources may not be reliable, the critical mind could reconstruct what really happened. Other historians instead just insert disclaimers in their books. These disclaimers basically state that the information presented might be from historically unreliable sources. So why did historians still use these sources? This fringes upon the fact that it is “not possible to write a historical biography of the Prophet without being accused of using the sources uncritically, while on the other hand, when using the sources critically, it is simply not possible to write such a biography “. Through all of the controversy and all of the doubts, everyday new developments in research arise, and some sources become more reliable and others less reliable. It will be interesting to see how information changes, and what new historical accounts emerge in the future, and how historical information on Muhammad will change over time. View More »

Read More

Related Essays on Issues in Reconstruction

  • Foreign Investments In Central Asia: Past, Present, And Future

    7354 words, 30 pages

    GEO55 Introduction Since their independence in 1991 Central Asian states have each struggled to keep up with the innovations and economies of the modern world. Much of the development in each country is contingent upon the ability for countries to gain foreign investment to build infrastructure and economies. In this paper I will analyze the state of Central Asian economies as they pertain to the natural resources, infrastructure, human resources, and government in each respective state. Each of these four categories helps define the current state and the future of foreign investment i

    View Document »

    Gender In Us Islamic And Orthodox Jewish Sacred Spaces

    6514 words, 27 pages

    ASMST 150 Introduction Across the globe there are millions of mosques and synagogues that serve as sacred sites for Muslims and Jews respectively. Each sacred site serves different purposes, including refuge for those less fortunate, a community center for the ethnic, a place of religious thought, a place of worship and prayer, and a place to share and rejoice with one another. The list goes on and on, but the underlying theme of all sacred sites is that they are to be a place of pilgrimage on the local, national, and global level. But pilgrimage for whom? There

    View Document »

    E-waste Nightmare: Guiyu, China

    4022 words, 17 pages

    Electronic waste, or E-waste, has become an increasingly large dilemma, especially in this day and age of the twenty-first century.  Many things about electronic waste is discussed here such as the causes and effects of E-Waste in general. More specifically, what is discussed is how humans have a large contributing factor to this problem.  The following also provides examples of any efforts humans are putting in to fix the waste.  More specifically, the paper discusses electronic waste in Guiyu, China and how it affects its residents and their lifestyle. Lastly, preventative measures are offe

    View Document »

    Rap And Hip-hop As Autoethnographies

    1995 words, 8 pages

    Mary Louise Pratt’s essay titled Arts of the Contact Zone explains how she perceives pieces of texts as autoethnographies. She defines this as texts “in which people undertake to describe themselves in ways that engage with representations others have made of them” (319). Such texts exist in today’s world in the form of songs and raps. In these particular autoethnographic texts, the musical artists create “contact zones” (319). At these “zones,” the artists clash with images others have made of them. Oftentimes, the “other” refers to a person or community who deems themselves far more superior

    View Document »

    Sociological Imagination

    2145 words, 9 pages

    SOCI 170 Sociological imagination, defined by the textbook, is “understanding human behavior by placing it within its broader social context” (p. 3). As defined in class, it is “the ability to use our private experiences and personal problems as a reflection of the society in which we live.” Basically, sociological imagination is the term used to define how an accumulation of certain experiences and problems views society. In relation to sociological imagination are the “big three” theoretical perspectives which are known as functionalism, conflict theory, and symbolic interactionism. These

    View Document »

    Bally Total Fitness Recommendation

    5736 words, 23 pages

    UGBA 106 Introduction The health club industry is an industry that is plagued with rapid growth and increasing competition. Clubs are struggling to stay competitive niche and emerging markets while remaining profitable. Many clubs seek multiple forms of revenue, Bally Total Fitness (Bally’s) being no exception. As one of the largest health conglomerates, Bally’s has had an interesting past riddled with successes and challenges. In the past few years, Bally’s has been largely scrutinized and has struggled to maintain positive net income and declining stock prices. This report serves as a re

    View Document »

    War On Drugs

    796 words, 4 pages

    SOCI 270 I argue that the war on drugs causes harm on many fronts such as racial injustice, denied access to education housing and benefits and wasted tax payers dollars. The war on drugs has been a war we have been losing for almost a century and continues to this day. This war has caused violent crimes that ravages our neighborhoods. Children of drug abusers are neglected, abused, and even abandoned, while drug abusers continue to fill courts, hospitals, and prisons. Taxing and regulating illicit drugs is not worth the cost if the war on drugs is leading to drug-related violence around th

    View Document »

    Lord Of The Flies And Beyond: What Faults Does Our Society Have?

    477 words, 2 pages

    William Golding, author of Lord of the Flies, believes that impatience is society’s biggest fault, while Catherine MacKinnon of the New York Times thinks that a lack of mutual respect for one another is our largest fault. Although Golding and MacKinnon may disagree about this, most of us can agree that both disrespect and impatience are issues in our society. In Lord of the Flies, the characters attempt to create an organized society, but the problem was that the boys were impatient, which lead to its inevitable downfall. The biggest example of impatience in the story is Jack, and his leavin

    View Document »

    Humanyze And How Employers Take Your Privacy For Granted

    824 words, 4 pages

    It would be pretty scary if someone kept track of our daily life. Our habits, interactions, secrets, and anything in between would be known by this person. He or she may even know more about us then we know about ourselves. With the advent of new technology, employers have seemingly gained this ability of surveillance. Current and prospective employees are screened through public social media. Some workplaces use devices that keep track of location, speed, and even tone of voice. While some of these developments are worrying, they are actually beneficial to use as long as employees’ privacy i

    View Document »

    Bailout

    3077 words, 13 pages

    UGBA107 Coming into his first term as President, a huge controversial issue that President Obama had to take a stand on was whether or not to bailout American car company General Motors, as the company was strongly affected by the weak United States economy. After advocating and eventually handing out a huge bailout several years ago, General Motors is again in the spotlight because of its large amounts of investment in plants in Mexico to outsource work. Many American taxpayers believe it is wrong for General Motors to give jobs to non-Americans especially after the huge government bailou

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!