Issues In Reconstruction

317 words, 2 pages

Intro Sample...


The main issues that center around the reconstruction the life of Muhammad are the validity and extent of validity of sources. Most sources are dated to two or three centuries after Muhammad passed, so this can also make sources questionable, although many believe that they are preserved because of the Islamic verbal tradition.
Controversy within sources mainly lies in hadith material. Ignaz Goldziher was one of the first scholars to challenge the validity of the hadith material, material that was before used by most scholars. He stated that the origin of the information is not clear, making the hadiths unreliable. In addition, without a basic chronological and topographical framework provided by the Muslim tradition, even sources like the Qur’an become almost useless for a historian trying to compile a biography on Muhammad.
Still, many historians continued to write historical accounts of Muhammad. Many believed that although many sources may not be reliable, the critical mind could reconstruct what really happened. Other historians instead just insert disclaimers in their books. These disclaimers basically state that the information presented might be from historically unreliable sources. So why did historians still use these sources? This fringes upon the fact that it is “not possible to write a historical biography of the Prophet without being accused of using the sources uncritically, while on the other hand, when using the sources critically, it is simply not possible to write such a biography “. Through all of the controversy and all of the doubts, everyday new developments in research arise, and some sources become more reliable and others less reliable. It will be interesting to see how information changes, and what new historical accounts emerge in the future, and how historical information on Muhammad will change over time. View More »

Read More

Related Essays on Issues in Reconstruction

  • Us History

    1256 words, 6 pages

    The word reconstruction means re-unification and rebuilding the utter destruction of the South in the Civil War. Building what was lost and what was damaged. It was a period where the South was building again to start over and become stronger than before. Reconstruction was a success in that it restored the United States as a unified nation, by 1877, all of the former Confederate states had drafted new constitutions, acknowledged the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments, and pledged their loyalty to the U.S. government. Reconstruction also finally settled th

    View Document »

    Short Term Significance Of Reconstruction On Black Population Of America

    1768 words, 8 pages

    What was the short-term significance of the policy of reconstruction on the black population of the South 1865-1877? The policy of reconstruction was basically a failure as there was an increase of fear, violence and prejudice by Southerners carried out against black people which meant that the lives of the newly freed slaves, although having new freedoms gifted to them, actually could be thought of becoming worse in some situations than they had been before the war as a consequence of what was known as Counter-Reconstruction. With the Civil War ending with the defeat

    View Document »

    Origins Of Civil Rights

    1786 words, 8 pages

    The modern Civil Rights Movement may be viewed as a sustained argument against the aftermath of Reconstruction. Reconstruction was supposed to usher in an era of emancipation, citizenship, and male suffrage for the newly-freed slaves as promised by the Civil War Amendments. But even as Congress had the power to enforce a measure of freedom for the former slaves, Freedmen instead met with labor conditions akin to slavery, second-class citizenship, and Jim Crow laws that limited their voting rights. Some may claim that the failure of Reconstruction was a consequence of feeble national leadershi

    View Document »

    Breast Cancer Fear. Heartache. Pain

    1763 words, 8 pages

    These are just a few feelings many men and women feel when they hear breast cancer. Breast cancer is a cancer that affects thousands of men and women yearly, has a few risk factors, and can be cured if detected early. Breast cancer has made hundreds of people so sick they do not feel like doing anything. Just think of the poor people who have gone through this disease and the ones who are going through it right now. Cancer, in general, is cells that do not reproduce properly. Breast cancer counts as 16% of all female cancers, 22.9% of invasive cancers, and 18.2% of all deaths in both men

    View Document »

    The Unequal Burden Of Tax: Tax Reform And The Civil War

    2293 words, 10 pages

    The taxation of the South and its people were of varying degrees and severity. At the onset of Reconstruction, Northerners had little sympathy to Southern economic plight. With the progression of Reconstruction and a slow realization that the tax laws were not helping the South, but rather stunting it, Northern Congressmen sought to lift the burden of taxes from the South. Northern thought during the Reconstruction shifted greatly from punishing the South with excise taxes and tariffs to identifying with the South’s need of economic growth and stability. While there was no absolute even ground

    View Document »

    Account For The Extent And Brutality Of Southern Violence In The Reconstruction Era

    1109 words, 5 pages

    The end of the Civil War in America in 1865 was just the beginning of an “unfinished Revolution” (Eric Foner); much of America was still in complete chaos in the wake of the War, and the Government was preoccupied with internal affairs, working hard to restore order within the Confederate states. The answer to the restoration problems was a period of Reconstruction; “a period of American history that has been so complex and ambiguous” (Foner), whereby the North tried desperately to get the eleven states that had seceded back into the Union. In answering a question on the period of Reconst

    View Document »

    America's Post Civil War Growing Pains

    1262 words, 6 pages

    The time of 1865-1890 is referred to as the Reconstruction and Industrialization period. During the reconstruction the Union was trying to figure out exactly how to deal with the evolution of life as they knew it. There were the seceded states and slaves that were now free. It was a very confusing time due to the many changes, and the new way of life that was coming to be. A lot of the problems during that time were actually similar to the problems that exist today. They were trying to figure out all the new issues that had arisen politically, trying to figure out what the right answer was

    View Document »

    African American S Lives After Reconstruction

    1002 words, 5 pages

    After the Civil War, African Americans yearned to achieve freedom overall, and without knowing it they would get it, but the South would find ways to deny them of their rights. This overall freedom meant that they wanted the ability to have equal civil rights, economic independence, political participation, and protection from abuse and any terror that local whites could threaten them with. Before reconstruction their desire of gaining such freedom seemed to be a distant dream that was just forgotten, but once they were granted with the rights they always hoped for, t

    View Document »


    1764 words, 8 pages

    The United States went through a period of turbulence and trouble in the second half of the 19th century. From the Compromise of 1850 to the Compromise of 1877, the country had to go through a variety of hardships, serious problems, and messes that it had to get itself out of. They say what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, and as the U.S. made it out alive from that time period, and so one would think they would emerge stronger and more unified than ever. One would also think that after the people realized the United States was a strong single nation and not just a

    View Document »

    Knowledge Is Power

    14210 words, 57 pages

    What is Knowledge? Chapter 1 WHAT IS KNOWLEDGE? 1 Most of the topics I shall be concerned with in this book concern kinds of knowledge: a priori knowledge, observational knowledge, and the possibility of having knowledge about objects and processes that, like the feelings of others or the micro-objects of current physics, cannot possibly be perceived. But these kinds of knowledge make sense only as instances of knowledge in a generic sense. Plato discussed knowledge of this generic sort in his Theaetetus, the first analytical study in epistemology, and the nature o

    View Document »

More Popular Essays

Research help is just moments away!